Days Until General Election:
            
Join the LP!
Get Involved!


LPedia.org


 
LP Blog
The official blog of the Libertarian Party



July 05, 2007

Your Patriotism Could be a Crime

This article comes to us from FoxNews.com about a new law in Minnesota that will take effect at the end of the year. The law, ironically sponsored by a Democrat, will require that all American flags sold in the state to have been made in the United States.

By year's end, a new law will require every Old Glory sold in Minnesota stores to be American made. It's the latest and strongest attempt by states to stem imports of foreign-made U.S. flags.

And apparently Minnesota is not the only state with laws like this one:

In Arizona, schools and public colleges were required starting July 1 to outfit every classroom from junior high up with a made-in-the-USA flag. Tennessee requires all U.S. flags bought via state contract to be made here, and similar bills are moving forward in both New Jersey and Pennsylvania.

At first glance, this must seem like the patriotic thing to do. After all, how can an American flag truly be American if the Chinese make it? I suppose one might call this a "preemptive war" on foreign flag manufacturers. You can't let the terrorists win by letting them produce our flags and get our money, even if they are far less expensive for consumers and it's what buyers prefer. That's just not American.

However, not everybody was keen on the measure (we call these people "traitors"):

"That flag should be made throughout the world because it is our message to the world that there is hope for freedom and justice," Republican Rep. Dan Severson said at the time.

Well, not really, Mr. Severson. Forbidding its sale more likely sends the message that the whole idea of private transaction without government interference, the founding philosophy of the United States,is not as highly regarded as it once was. But hey, it sounds good as long as you don't think about it.

Another issue is whether or not this new state law violates World Trade Organization standards:

Under World Trade Organization standards, the U.S. government can't treat foreign products less favorably than those produced within its boundaries, said Peter Morici, a business professor at the University of Maryland and the former chief economist for the U.S. International Trade Commission. How the rules apply to states is debatable, he said.

For now, the law's sponsor, Democratic Rep. Tom Rukavina, is happy with his victory over the "terrorist nations" who defile our flag with their grimy, un-American hands:

To celebrate his legislative victory, he plans to hand out 1,000 miniature flags at Fourth of July parades in his district.
"The biggest honor that you can give the flag is that it be made by American workers in the United States of America," he said. "Nothing is more embarrassing to me than a plastic flag made in China. This replica of freedom we so respect should be made in this country."

Evidently your American flag only represents freedom if it has the "Made in the USA" logo proudly stamped on it. So, be sure to hide all your foreign-made American flags, lest you have the Minnesota Flag Police storming into your yard with torches blazing.

I just wonder how Mr. Rukavina is going to feel about his victory once he realizes his 1,000 little flags were probably made by Mexican immigrants working in the manufacturing plants.

Oops.

Posted by Andrew Davis at July 5, 2007 12:29 PM

Reader Comments:

FLORIDA Statutes 1000.06 (2)


Each public K-20 educational institution that is provided or authorized by the Constitution and laws of Florida shall display daily in each classroom the flag of the United States.

The flag must be made in the United States, must be at least 2 feet by 3 feet, and must be properly displayed in accordance with Title 4 U.S.C.

Posted by: Jack Tanner at July 5, 2007 03:47 PM

I think this is simple-minded thinking that gets the "cheap applause" that politicians so eagerly and easily gain from the general populace of no-brain redneck Americans. Anybody that knows the basics of economics and free trade will be able to figure that one out.

I think these laws are stupid and there is no reason for them.

Posted by: Steve at July 6, 2007 09:09 AM

This is so stupid.

If you want to buy a flag made in America, just look for a tag that says "Made in America". If you want a cheap one, don't worry about it.

Why do we need laws for things like this? Maybe the politicians are depressed over the beating they have been getting from their constituents the past several months and are looking for an easy way to maybe get some kudos.

If they pass this and I find a flag made in China, can I sue somebody?

Posted by: Matt at July 6, 2007 10:22 AM

Dissent against tyrannical government is supposed to be the most patriotic thing an American can do. Of course, the government calls dissent unpatriotic and un-American. Why does anyone listen to them at all? Are Americans really that stupid? It's a shame there are so many stupid people in this country. And they blame the smart ones for all the problems. Ugh.

Posted by: Nick at July 6, 2007 11:18 AM

There's a good artlice about this very subject here: http://www.freecapitalist.com/columnists/keogh_archives.php?id=152

Posted by: medford at July 6, 2007 11:39 AM

Okay, so if I create a flag on my vacation in Spain (hypothetical; I've never been to Spain, but I kinda like the music), I can't sell it in Minnesota?

Remind me not to go to Minnesota. I suppose if I sold flags on eBay, I'd have to refuse to send them to buyers in certain states? Why are they wasting our tax dollars on this? This is legislative malpractice.

Posted by: Sandra at July 6, 2007 01:12 PM

What is most disappointing about websites like this is the use of words like "stupid," "redneck," etc. to characterize people with rights and opinions just like ours. Hyperbole and name-calling are best left to television news reporting, let's conduct ourselves as considerate thinkers.

Posted by: Mike at July 6, 2007 02:21 PM

OK, so let me see if I have this right...

Politicians like saying how our flag and country represent freedom but in order to be patriotic we must stop people from freely purchasing what they want... Hmmmm... Do I smell hypocrisy?

Posted by: Jason at July 6, 2007 06:24 PM

A state-wide law? That's rediculous. But, what is wrong with a law requiring state property to buy American made flags?

Posted by: william at July 6, 2007 10:03 PM
 


Blog Archives
 Va. Libertarian candidate endorsed by major district newspaper

 LNC National Secretary, Bob Sullentrup, on XM Radio

 Speeches from the CLC in Reno

 Barr, Redpath on Oklahoma radio

 Newspaper endorses Indiana Libertarian candidate

 The 'Silver Tsunami'

 Democrats Sell-Out on FISA (Again)

 Coming to America

 Iraqi clockwork oranges

 Greenspan unleashed



By Month:
 October 2007

 September 2007

 August 2007

 July 2007

 June 2007

 May 2007

 April 2007

 March 2007

 February 2007

 January 2007

 December 2006

 November 2006

 October 2006

 September 2006

 August 2006

 July 2006

 June 2006

 May 2006

 April 2006

 March 2006

 February 2006

 January 2006

 December 2005

 November 2005

 October 2005

 September 2005

 August 2005

 July 2005

 June 2005

 May 2005

 April 2005


LP State Orgs
Search LP.org
Libertarian National Committee, Inc. - 2008 - Privacy Policy
Paid for by the Libertarian National Committee -- 2600 Virginia Ave, N.W. Suite 200, Washington D.C. 20037 -- 1-800-Elect-Us
Content not authorized by any candidate or candidate committee